Joey Votto, a guy who poured his heart and soul into 17 seasons with the Cincinnati Reds, dropped a truth bomb on “Sunday Night Baseball” July 26 that’s still got people talking. He laid out a truly painful memory for Reds fans, one that even *he* admits is how some cities remember his career, and frankly, it’s brutal. We’re talking about Roy Halladay’s legendary no-hitter against the Reds back in the 2010 National League Division Series, a moment Votto clearly hasn’t, and probably never will, forget.
That Stinging Truth About His Legacy
When Bob Costas, the broadcast icon, asked Votto on national television if people nationwide don’t truly appreciate his long career, Votto’s reply was pure, unvarnished honesty. He didn’t dance around it. He just said, “Any Philly fan knows the Cincinnati Reds because we were no-hit on this field vs. Roy Halladay in 2010.” Just imagine that for a second. This man spent nearly two decades with one club, a team that was, as Costas himself pointed out, a “contender occasionally but not often.” And Votto knows that for an entire city, the defining memory of his time there is a soul-crushing postseason loss. That’s a punch to the gut.
He went even further, straight up admitting that Phillies fans “may know me, but not for the right reasons.” That’s a deep cut, the kind of confession that shows just how profoundly these moments stick with athletes, even years after the final out. Halladay, in an absolutely dominant performance, tossed that no-hitter in his very first-ever postseason appearance. It was a 4-0 Phillies win in Game 1 of the NLDS, on October 6, 2010. It wasn’t just a loss, it was a piece of humiliating baseball history Votto was on the wrong side of, and he still feels it.
Reflecting on What Was, And Who’s Next
Votto’s recent media tour hasn’t shied away from reflection. A few days before the “Sunday Night Baseball” appearance, on July 22, he was on MLB Network’s “MLB Now” alongside Brian Kenny, Costas, and Jake Peavy. He delivered another sobering thought for Reds fans, mentioning he never got to experience anything like the Boston Red Sox’s recent surge with their winning streak and turnaround. It’s a clear indication that the lack of consistent team success, despite his personal excellence, still weighs heavily on him.
But it wasn’t all looking back at the past. Votto also took a moment to scout the current game, and surprisingly, he saw a bit of himself in a young talent. When MLB Network asked him last week about a current hitter who reminds him of himself, Votto named Boston Red Sox outfielder Roman Anthony. It’s an interesting choice, showing that even while reflecting on his own career’s ups and downs, Votto still has a sharp eye for talent and recognizes similarities in today’s game. His honesty on national television is a powerful reminder that even for the game’s absolute best, some moments, particularly the painful ones, never truly fade.
This article was created with AI assistance and published under Seattle On Tap’s editorial standards. See our Editorial Policy.
Originally reported by Yahoo Sports.
Leave a Reply