Seattle sports, on tap daily

174 Yards and Three Interceptions: Todd McShay’s Blunt Take on Arch Manning’s NFL Future Is the Real Story

Nfl logo on gradient background

Written by

in

Nfl logo on gradient background
Nfl logo on gradient background — Created by the Sports On Tap desk | Source : Sports On Tap (team logos property of their respective owners)

NFL draft guru Todd McShay just dropped a truth bomb on the future of quarterbacks Arch Manning and Sam Leavitt, suggesting both players need another year of college ball before even thinking about the NFL. Despite Manning throwing a last-second touchdown to secure a 22-21 win for Texas over LSU, McShay made it clear on Monday’s episode of The McShay Show that “neither is ready for the NFL right now.” This is a stark assessment after a weekend that, for all its drama, highlighted serious struggles for both young signal-callers.

The Brutal Honesty About Top Prospects

McShay did not mince words, but it wasn’t all negative. He projects Manning and Leavitt “to be dynamic quarterbacks that have a path to be good starters in the NFL and can win a ton of games in the NFL and can possibly win a Super Bowl in the NFL.” He credits them with “physical tools and enough instinct and playmaking skills.” That’s high praise for their long-term ceiling, no doubt. But the catch? “I also thank god for both of them; they have another year of college,” McShay stated. It’s a sentiment that hits hard, especially when you consider where Manning currently sits in mock drafts. This isn’t just about potential, it’s about present-day readiness, and McShay sees a gap.

Arch Manning’s Game-Winner Can’t Hide the Flaws

Manning’s game-winning touchdown against LSU was the highlight reel moment everyone saw, but the stats behind it tell a different story. He finished the game with just 174 yards through the air, completing 19-of-35 passes and throwing three crippling interceptions. He did manage to tie for the team lead with 35 rushing yards and added a score on the ground, showing some versatility. Still, those three picks are glaring. It’s the kind of performance that makes you wonder if the hype machine is running ahead of the actual development. While B/R’s NFL Scouting Department still has Manning pegged as the fourth overall pick, going to the New York Jets in their latest mock draft, you have to think McShay’s take is going to resonate with scouts.

Leavitt’s Struggles and Draft Reality

Sam Leavitt’s performance wasn’t much better, and his draft stock reflects it. He went 27-of-37 for 244 yards and two touchdowns, but also tossed three interceptions as LSU fell to a 6-4 season record. Unlike Manning, Leavitt is not currently projected as a first-round selection. Both QBs delivered performances against LSU that solidified McShay’s stance: they need more time. The idea of these guys using their final year of college eligibility to truly hone their skills before making the leap in 2028 seems less like a suggestion and more like an absolute necessity if they want to live up to that “dynamic quarterback” projection. What does this mean for the 2027 draft class? It means a couple of big names might be off the board, giving them crucial time to develop.

This article was created with AI assistance and published under Seattle On Tap’s editorial standards. See our Editorial Policy.

Originally reported by Bleacher Report.

About the author

Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *