
Indiana dropped from No. 4 to No. 9 in the College Football Playoff poll last week when six of their previously faced Big Ten opponents lost, but Alabama stayed firm at No. 3 *this* week even after five SEC teams they previously beat also took L’s. You gotta be kidding me, right? This week’s poll, folks, is a whopper of a benefit of the doubt for one program.
You Can’t Make This Stuff Up: Indiana vs. Bama
Let’s walk through this, because the CFP selection committee’s decision-making is starting to look like a joke. A week ago, Indiana was on a bye. What happened? All six of its previously faced Big Ten opponents lost. The committee then said “nope” to Indiana’s No. 4 spot, dropping them to No. 9. CFP chairman Hunter Yurachek even tried to explain it: “Three things happened to Indiana. One were the conference losses, and there were five games involved with Top 14 teams, so there was (poll) movement around Indiana. And Indiana had a bye and didn’t have an opportunity to improve its resume.” Okay, fine. Rules are rules, right?
Then we fast forward to last weekend. Alabama, after what was described as an “ugly win at Vanderbilt,” stayed firm at No. 3. Want to guess what happened with *their* schedule? Five SEC teams that Alabama had previously beaten *also lost*. So, Indiana’s opponents lose, they drop. Alabama’s opponents lose, they don’t budge. The blatant “rules for thee and not for me” nonsense is just impossible to ignore.
That “Quality of Strength of Schedule” Gibberish
If you thought Yurachek’s explanation for Indiana was a stretch, wait until you hear the pretzel logic for Alabama. He actually said Alabama didn’t move down, and the five opponent losses didn’t have the same impact as they did on Indiana because , get this , “the quality of strength of schedule those five teams had lost.” What the hell does that even mean? The committee expects us to believe this gibberish? They sent this guy out with notes, knowing full well the Indiana/Alabama comparison was coming, and *this* was the best they could do? It sounds a whole lot like the committee just decided Alabama didn’t drop because… well, because it’s Alabama.
And if that wasn’t enough, let’s talk about Tennessee. Alabama’s 16-point loss to Tennessee, remember that? Last weekend, Tennessee went on the road and whipped Texas A&M , worse than Alabama did in Tuscaloosa, by the way , and what happened to Tennessee? They dropped from No. 8 to No. 9! After a *better* win against a common opponent! Yurachek actually said, “The committee really values Tennessee.” Hunter, babe, I don’t think they do. It’s painfully obvious the committee values Alabama’s near win against Georgia in Tuscaloosa as the single most important game of the season, and it apparently supersedes any other metric. They just need to admit it already.
This weekly dancing around the truth is getting old. How can we trust these rankings when the rules seem to change depending on the team? It makes you wonder what we’re even watching for.
This article was created with AI assistance and published under Seattle On Tap’s editorial standards. See our Editorial Policy.
Originally reported by Yahoo Sports.
Leave a Reply