Seattle sports, on tap daily

The Morgan Rogers Handball Was The Right Call, And Nobody In The Premier League Is Ready For It

Spain flag on gradient background

Written by

in

Spain flag on gradient background
Spain flag on gradient background — Created by the Sports On Tap desk | Source : Sports On Tap (team logos property of their respective owners)

It happened again on Saturday: a crucial penalty call, this time against Chelsea’s Morgan Rogers in their brutal 4-1 home defeat by Leeds. That penalty put the visitors ahead for the first time, and it is reigniting the Premier League’s endless handball debate, even though, by the letter of the law, this one was absolutely correct.

The PL’s Wildly Different Handball Reality

You might think handball penalties are flying left and right in the Premier League, especially with all the noise, but here is the wild truth: they are much rarer here than in Europe’s other top five leagues. Last season, across 380 Premier League games, there were just 22 handball penalties. That was the lowest tally by far, with Spain’s La Liga racking up 36 and Italy’s Serie A leading the pack with 38. This season? We have only seen three in 106 matches, which is actually less than we got in 2025-26. So, what made Rogers’ handball different enough to get the whistle?

Premier League clubs generally feel like the handball interpretation is in a good spot: an arm has to be fully extended, raised, or it has to be a deliberate act to get penalized. And that last one, the deliberate act, is exactly what applied to Rogers, even if it might feel a little harsh given the PL’s generally more relaxed approach.

Why Michael Oliver Pointed To The Spot

Referee Michael Oliver had a clear path to pointing to the spot, and VAR Michael Salisbury staying out of it was also totally justifiable. There were a couple of key things going on. First, Jayden Bogle’s shot came from distance. When the ball travels a bit, a defender is expected to have more time to adjust their body and avoid any potential handball. But the big, big factor here was Rogers’ arm movement. When Bogle struck the ball, Rogers’ arm was not up. But get this: it came up right into the flight of the ball! If his arm had stayed in its original position, lower and level with his midriff, there would not have been a handball offence.

But that is not what happened. Rogers raised his arm, and that is what deflected the ball away. That action, right there, is considered a deliberate act, and it trumps everything else. There was a tiny question about whether the ball hit too high on his arm, in what they call the ‘red zone’ for handball, but it looked to be squarely within that punishable area. That would have been the only real reason for a VAR review, and honestly, it was not enough.

The Precedent Is There, Like It Or Not

We actually saw a similar situation last season, also involving a penalty awarded to Leeds. Remember when Everton’s James Tarkowski leaned into Anton Stach’s powerful strike? His arm was tucked tight to his side, but he deliberately leaned into the ball’s path. Everton manager David Moyes called that decision “wrong,” but the law said it was absolutely correct. The arm being close to his body was irrelevant because of the deliberate act of leaning into the path of the ball.

It was the same story with Rogers: he raised his arm to stop the ball. That makes it a justifiable penalty call, plain and simple. So, while the Premier League tries to keep things a bit more lenient, this decision just hammers home how much dissatisfaction there still is with the handball law, even when the call is technically spot on.

This article was created with AI assistance and published under Seattle On Tap’s editorial standards. See our Editorial Policy.

Originally reported by BBC Sport.

About the author

Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *