Seattle sports, on tap daily

Replays Scream Jameis Winston Was Down, Yet Officials Called It a Touchdown Anyway

Jacksonville Jaguars logo on gradient background

Written by

in

Jacksonville Jaguars logo on gradient background
Jacksonville Jaguars logo on gradient background — Created by the Sports On Tap desk | Source : Sports On Tap (team logos property of their respective owners)

Jameis Winston, quarterback for the Giants, just got handed a touchdown on a fourth-and-goal tush push today against the Jaguars, but if you saw the replays, you know this one looks like a gift. It really seems like Winston never actually broke the plane.

The Call That Wasn’t

Winston plunged into a pile of bodies, a classic tush push play, and the officials on the field threw up their hands, signaling six points. But as soon as the replays started rolling, it was clear something was off. His helmet appeared to hit the turf before that pigskin even thought about crossing the goal line. It was a bang-bang play, sure, but the visual evidence immediately raised eyebrows.

No Review, No Problem? Think Again.

What makes this even wilder? The play wasn’t stopped for a replay review! Seriously, in an era where every single blade of grass is scrutinized, this critical call just… stood. Former NFL referee Gene Steratore, calling the game on the CBS broadcast, didn’t mince words. He said straight up that it “did not appear to be a touchdown.” That’s an ex-ref, with all his experience, saying the guys on the field got it wrong, and still, no challenge, no review. We’re talking a potential phantom score in a game where the Giants already hold a 10-3 lead over the Jaguars at the start of the second quarter. While there wasn’t a “perfect” replay angle, and the Jaguars were flagged for offside, meaning the Giants would’ve gotten another shot even if Winston was ruled short, it still feels like a massive miscue.

This isn’t just about one play, it’s about the trust in the officiating. When a former referee says it’s not a touchdown, and the replays back him up, you have to wonder how a call like this stands. Let’s hope the league is taking notes on this one.

This article was created with AI assistance and published under Seattle On Tap’s editorial standards. See our Editorial Policy.

Originally reported by Pro Football Talk.

About the author

Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *