The Minnesota Vikings got absolutely clobbered by the Denver Broncos, a brutal 34-6 loss in a preseason game on August 28. But honestly, the score isn’t even the wildest news coming out of Minnesota right now. What’s truly blowing up the discussion boards is a baffling decision by J.J. McCarthy that has everyone scratching their heads.
Dude, we heard all summer J.J. was grinding, putting in the work on his mechanics and footwork, trying to level up his game. Reports coming out of OTAs even had folks buzzing that his mechanics were looking sharper. But then training camp kicked off, and it was like déjà vu. The reports quickly shifted, painting a picture “remarkably similar to 2025 training camp,” meaning the same old accuracy issues and that frustrating “one-speed passing” were still a problem. This was all after he’d initially split first-team reps with Kyler Murray in a “competition” that fizzled fast, with Murray getting the starting QB nod just ten days into August.
Then things got even weirder. After the second preseason game, the talk started about whether McCarthy was even a lock for QB2. Carson Wentz suddenly looked “smoother and more comfortable running the offense,” leading to speculation that Vikings head coach Kevin O’Connell might actually trust Wentz more than McCarthy if Murray went down. And if McCarthy wasn’t even the backup, would the Vikings keep him as a QB3? That led to the ultimate gut punch: trade speculation as roster cutdown day loomed.
The stakes were already sky-high, and then McCarthy apparently tweaked his ankle after the Ravens preseason game. Both he and O’Connell thought it was minor, and McCarthy even said he didn’t expect to miss any games. He practiced twice that week, showing zero signs of injury, and was only held out of Wednesday’s practice as a “precautionary measure.” O’Connell even planned for McCarthy to start and play the entire first half of the final preseason game, a huge chance to showcase his skills. But on game day? McCarthy told O’Connell he “wasn’t comfortable playing.” Let that sink in. He’d been cleared by doctors, the team said it was safe, but McCarthy himself pulled the plug. This wasn’t the team sidelining him; it was McCarthy taking himself out of the biggest opportunity he might get all season.
That move, refusing to play when cleared, has sent the speculation into overdrive about his true motivations. For a guy who might be QB3 and potentially not see the field for a year, passing up his last chance to play and showcase his talent for potentially a year? That’s just wild. What does this mean for the Vikings’ QB depth chart moving forward? It sure looks like Wentz has leapfrogged him, and now, who knows what happens next for McCarthy as the season officially kicks off.
This article was created with AI assistance and published under Seattle On Tap’s editorial standards. See our Editorial Policy.
Originally reported by Daily Norseman.
Leave a Reply