Week 3 is staring us down, and if you are deep into fantasy football, you know the grind is real. Our Yahoo rankers are locked in, but they’re seeing some serious split opinions on a few key names this week. We’re talking about players with “coefficient of variation” off the charts, the kind of guys who make or break your lineup decisions.
The Pass-Catchers: Trusting Schultz, Doubting Downs?
Let’s kick it off with Dalton Schultz, who’s got a juicy matchup at Indianapolis. He’s projected for 50.5 receiving yards, but the disagreement is wild. Our rankers are all over the map, with positional ranks from 7 all the way to 11. That’s a four-spot difference, making him a true swing player. Here’s why: this assumes Nico Collins is still out with that hamstring injury, and honestly, the Texans have nobody else stepping up as a go-to receiver. Without Collins last week, Schultz was TE1 overall, racking up 16.6 expected half PPR points. The dude is trusted over the middle, and who do the Colts have guarding that spot? Their linebackers, who are arguably the worst in the NFL and have been “absolutely crushed” through two weeks. Schultz actually lit them up for 73 yards back in Week 18 last season, so yeah, it’s a “great spot again” for him.
Then there’s Josh Downs, facing Houston at home, also with a 50.5 projected receiving yardage. But the opinions on Downs are even more spread out, with a 14-spot difference between the highest (23) and lowest (37) rankings! Alec Pierce’s surgically-repaired heel/ankle had a setback, and we might not see him again this year. Low-volume grinder Laquon Treadwell is filling in until newly-signed Darius Slayton gets acclimated, and even Keenan Allen’s early returns have been “quite suspect.” So, Daniel Jones is consolidating targets, which sounds great for Downs. In five games since 2024 with Pierce out or seeing one target, Downs has a “very startable” 23.5% target share , that kind of volume is gold. Downs is WR21 in expected half PPR points through two weeks, and he got 13.8 expected half PPR points (WR14) last week, getting open with those sweet “hop, skip and a jump” moves and “free releases off cheat motions.”
But hold up! The matchup is “very difficult.” The Texans were fifth-best against fantasy WRs last season. They get beaten by “big-bodied downfield threats,” not necessarily slot guys like Downs. Downs actually torched them for 4 catches, 109 yards, and a score in Week 8 of 2024, which was awesome, but he’s been held under 50 scoreless yards in his other four games against them. The Colts won’t have Pierce this time, and Daniel Jones is under center, so maybe he performs better. WR1s Ja’Marr Chase and D.J. Moore both had 75+ yards and a score against Houston this year, so it is possible.
The Committee Back: Jeremiyah Love
Finally, we’ve got Jeremiyah Love heading into San Francisco, projected for 63.5 total yards. He’s another divisive one, with rankings from 20 to 27. Love “remains a clear 1-2 punch committee” in that backfield. He kicked off the season strong with 13.2 expected half PPR points in Week 1’s upset win, but last week he dipped to 8.2 expected points. You are betting on that upside in a tough matchup, hoping he gets enough work in that committee to hit his ceiling.
Fantasy is all about chasing the upside and dodging the landmines, especially in Week 3. With these three polarizing players, your lineup decisions could swing the whole week. Make sure you are checking in on our weekly rankings pages and the Sunday AM sit/start show for the absolute latest updates before those crucial kickoffs. Every point counts, especially with a season on the line in these early weeks!
This article was created with AI assistance and published under Seattle On Tap’s editorial standards. See our Editorial Policy.
Originally reported by Yahoo Sports.
Leave a Reply