John Harbaugh just dropped a bombshell, telling the world he doubts Tom Brady could even come back from retirement and be ready from week one. This wasn’t some offhand comment, either. The New York Giants coach was actually talking about his *own* quarterback situation.
The New QB in Town and the GOAT Analogy
The Giants are rolling with J.J. McCarthy for his first start this Sunday against the Houston Texans. This move comes after McCarthy stepped in for Jameis Winston in Week 6’s loss to the New Orleans Saints. And listen, the kid showed up, slinging for 243 yards and a touchdown in the fourth quarter and leading three scoring drives. The Giants went out and traded for McCarthy last month because Jaxson Dart got hit with a season-ending injury. Harbaugh bringing up Brady? It was all about making a point on McCarthy’s journey. He used the future Pro Football Hall of Famer in an analogy to describe McCarthy’s need to learn the offense over the last few weeks before being inserted into the lineup.
Harbaugh’s Jaw-Dropping Brady Take
Harbaugh used Brady as the ultimate example of why a new QB, even a GOAT, needs time. He said, and I’m quoting here, “If Tom Brady decided he wanted to come back from retirement and actually could, which I doubt for one second he could, no matter what he thinks, you heard me, Tom , I don’t think he’d be ready the first week.” He stressed that even one of the smartest signal callers in NFL history would need time to acclimate to a new scheme. McCarthy’s definitely adjusting to a new scheme himself, having played 10 games last season, 2025, for the Minnesota Vikings. In that season, he completed 140 of 243 passes for 1,632 yards, 11 touchdowns, and 12 interceptions after missing his entire rookie year due to injury. Harbaugh’s team has expanded its playbook to 90 percent for McCarthy already, and offensive coordinator Matt Nagy said they want to keep play calls “manageable” for McCarthy in his first start.
Brady’s Actual Plans: Still Happily Retired
So, is Brady even thinking about a comeback after that kind of challenge? Nah, not as a player, at least. He’s been asking about the league’s policy on minority owners suiting up. Brady’s got an ownership stake in the Las Vegas Raiders, even helped them out with advisory decisions this offseason. He’s on record saying, “I actually have inquired, and they don’t like that idea very much. We explored a lot of different things, and I’m very happily retired. Let me just say that, too.” So while Harbaugh was playfully jabbing him, Brady’s chilling, calling it quits for real on the playing field.
This Sunday, all eyes are on J.J. McCarthy. He’s got a big opportunity ahead as the Giants adjust their offense to his strengths. Even if Harbaugh was using Brady to make a point about development, the echoes of that challenge will definitely be part of the NFL conversation for a while.
This article was created with AI assistance and published under Seattle On Tap’s editorial standards. See our Editorial Policy.
Originally reported by CBS Sports.
Leave a Reply