A three-year, $55 million contract is on the table for David Bednar, a prediction from The Athletic’s Jim Bowden that puts the Yankees’ most important bullpen arm squarely in the offseason spotlight. This isn’t just about a paycheck, it’s about the New York Yankees needing to decide if they are ready to break their own rules for the best reliever on the market.
The Numbers Don’t Lie: Why Bednar’s So Valuable
Let’s be real, Bednar was the absolute backbone of that Yankees bullpen this year. The guy was a two-time All-Star, and for good reason. He posted a ridiculous 2.39 ERA across 86 outings and racked up 45 saves since joining the team. Bowden nailed it: Bednar was a lockdown closer, saving 35 games with a 2.47 ERA and a 2.61 FIP in 69 1/3 innings just this season. He punched out 76 batters, with a whopping 50 of those coming from his absolutely filthy split-fingered fastball. Opposing hitters basically stood no chance against it, batting a measly .149. That’s elite, folks. He proved he can handle the pressure cooker that is New York, and that’s something you just can’t teach.
Yankees Have To Pay Up, Or Watch Him Walk
Here’s where it gets spicy. Jim Bowden called the Yankees Bednar’s “best team fit,” which makes total sense given what he did for them. But everyone knows the Yankees don’t usually go big on relievers. Bednar is 32, which usually gives some teams pause, but his performance absolutely screams “big payday.” The real problem for the Yankees? They don’t have anyone ready to step into those shoes. A shutdown closer, especially one who handles New York like it’s a walk in the park, is an incredibly rare commodity. Bednar is going to get a ton of interest, especially from big-market teams looking for that kind of reliability. The bottom line: the Yankees simply cannot afford to lose him.
With the offseason officially here, the stakes couldn’t be higher for the Yankees. Losing a two-time All-Star closer who literally held their bullpen together would be a gut punch, and finding a replacement for Bednar’s lockdown presence won’t be easy. Will they break tradition and pay up, or risk watching their most crucial arm walk away to a rival?
This article was created with AI assistance and published under Seattle On Tap’s editorial standards. See our Editorial Policy.
Originally reported by Yahoo Sports.
Leave a Reply