Indianapolis Colts are demanding a first-round pick plus *even more* for superstar running back Jonathan Taylor, and you won’t believe which team is actually in the mix: the New York Giants. Easton Butler of Packer Report dropped the bombshell, saying the Colts are looking for an “astronomically costly” return for Taylor, but Big Blue is still reportedly eyeing him hard.
Indy’s Fire Sale and a Wild Price Tag
The Colts are clearly in full-on fire sale and rebuild mode, especially after finally firing general manager Chris Ballard. That move was long overdue, and honestly, holding onto a player like Taylor during a multi-year rebuild just doesn’t make any sense. They want to strike now, get a massive haul, and use it to kickstart their future. We’re talking a first-rounder *and then some* for a running back, a position that’s been devalued like crazy across the league. But let’s be real: if *anyone* can command that kind of price, it’s Taylor. He’s one of the truly elite players at his position in the NFL, no question. The league knows it, and the Colts are banking on it.
Giants’ RB Room Is a Train Wreck
So, why are the Giants even thinking about paying such a ridiculous price? Simple: their running back room is a mess. Head coach John Harbaugh loves to pound the rock, but what’s he got right now? Cam Skattebo has been ineffective this season, and he’s currently riding the pine in the dog house because of fumbling issues. Behind him, Tyrone Tracy isn’t exactly a lead back. And remember Najee Harris? He was cut after complaining about how the Giants used their backs in Week 6. It’s a disaster, plain and simple. Taylor would be a total game-changer for that offense, a fantastic runner and a very good pass-catcher. He would make Jaxson Dart’s life so much easier for years to come with his ability to just take over games.
Early Season First Place, But at What Cost?
Here’s the tricky part for the Giants: they’re in Year 1 of Harbaugh’s tenure, and yeah, they’re in first place right now. But let’s not pretend they’re suddenly a powerhouse. They’ve had a soft schedule, and honestly, they could easily have a few more losses if things hadn’t bounced their way. Plus, their entire division is a total disaster right now. So, the Giants have to walk a really fine line. Giving up significant draft capital when you’re still building, even with a first-place record, is risky. But, and this is a big “but,” running backs as good as Taylor don’t hit the market often, and he’s under contract through 2028. So, this isn’t just a “win now” move. Taylor could help this team for at least a few more years. Are the Giants desperate enough to make this wild gamble? We’re all waiting to see if Big Blue pulls the trigger on this potentially season-defining trade.
This article was created with AI assistance and published under Seattle On Tap’s editorial standards. See our Editorial Policy.
Originally reported by The Sporting News.
Leave a Reply