Michigan is staring down a brutal 0-2 Big Ten start, and QB Bryce Underwood just delivered another performance that has everyone in Ann Arbor asking, “What the heck is going on?” After a crushing 20-14 loss to Minnesota, where Underwood was, straight-up, awful, his starting job is suddenly on serious thin ice. This isn’t just a bad game, folks, this is the first time since Brady Hoke’s final year in 2014 that the Wolverines are 0-2 in conference play.
The Nightmare Under Center Just Got Real
Underwood’s stat line against Minnesota was a total gut punch: he completed fewer than 50% of his passes, managed only 101 yards, and threw two interceptions without a single touchdown. Yikes. Coach Kyle Whittingham wouldn’t even give Underwood a direct vote of support after the game, confirming the staff is actually “evaluating” a QB change during the bye week. Whittingham said, “Well, you always want to think about what gives you the best chance to win throughout the entire course of the game.”
Honestly, it’s not even a secret that Whittingham hasn’t been a big fan of Underwood since taking over. Remember that “right now” comment after the inconsistent opener against Western Michigan? That was a red flag, only saved by a Hail Mary at the buzzer. Looking at his season so far, in three games against Power Four competition, Underwood is completing just 55% of his passes, throwing for a measly 162.7 yards per game, with only two touchdowns against three interceptions. Michigan is barely scraping by, averaging just 16.7 points in those matchups. This isn’t the big-time football everyone expected.
Is There Anyone Else, Or Is This a Bigger Problem?
Let’s be real, this kid was one of the biggest recruiting wins in program history, flipped from LSU, and now the investment looks like it’s backfiring. So, what are the options? Senior Brayden Fowler-Nicolosi is on the roster, a multi-year starter from Colorado State. But hold up, this dude was a total turnover machine for the Rams, leading the nation with 16 picks in 2023. He even got benched after three games for CSU last season. So, is he really the answer?
Then there’s freshman Tommy Carr, a four-star recruit who’s apparently impressed everyone since stepping on campus. He’s got the pedigree, too, being the brother of Notre Dame’s CJ Carr and grandson of former Michigan coach Lloyd Carr. Could this raw talent bring some consistency? It’s a huge gamble.
And here’s the thing: Underwood isn’t entirely without a role, nearly leading the Wolverines in rushing. Plus, let’s be real, this isn’t *all* on Bryce. The Wolverines are a mess across the board, ranking a dismal 14th in the Big Ten in yards per carry and coming into the weekend 114th in penalty yardage gap. How’s any QB supposed to thrive in that?
Coach Whittingham has a bye week to figure this mess out, and you know he’s gotta be feeling the heat. Does he stick with the high-upside, struggling sophomore, or does he roll the dice on a known turnover machine or a talented but unproven freshman? Whatever he decides, the entire future of Michigan’s season hangs in the balance. You better believe all eyes will be on Ann Arbor when they hit the field again.
This article was created with AI assistance and published under Seattle On Tap’s editorial standards. See our Editorial Policy.
Originally reported by CBS Sports.
Leave a Reply