Eight teams from the Southeastern Conference just got ranked higher in the College Football Playoff rankings than they were in this week’s Associated Press poll. If that doesn’t scream “SEC favoritism,” then I don’t know what does. The selection committee unveiled its first in-season CFP rankings on Tuesday night, and it caused major confusion and frustration across college football, mostly thanks to some seriously inconsistent logic that only seemed to make sense for one conference.
The SEC’s Unshakeable Grip on the Committee
The committee’s love affair with the SEC isn’t just a hunch, it’s a full-blown declaration. Two two-loss SEC teams even landed ahead of undefeated UCLA! That’s a bold statement about “strength of schedule” from a conference that never shuts up about theirs. Alabama, a two-loss team, is sitting pretty at No. 5, getting a ton of credit for beating one-loss Kentucky. But get this: two-loss Tennessee, which absolutely smoked Alabama by three scores just two weeks ago, is somehow eight spots lower than the Tide. What gives?
This isn’t just about Alabama and Tennessee, though. The committee consistently elevated SEC teams across the board. Alabama is four spots above its AP ranking. Kentucky, Texas, Ole Miss, Tennessee, LSU, Missouri, and South Carolina all checked in ahead of their AP rankings too. That’s eight teams total! While the AP Top 25 isn’t gospel, it clearly shows the committee has a much rosier view of these SEC squads than pretty much anyone else. They’re getting all the credit for wins and barely dinged for losses, even the lopsided ones. Sounds a lot like what their coaches have been lobbying for all offseason, doesn’t it?
Committee Logic? More Like Committee Confusion
The head-to-head results seemed to matter for some teams, but totally disappear for others. Take Notre Dame at No. 11. They’re seven spots lower than their AP poll ranking. Committee chairman Hunter Yurachek said it was because of their “weak schedule,” claiming the Irish don’t have a “signature win” over a current Top 25 team. Okay, fair enough, they don’t. But then there’s Indiana. The Hoosiers have one loss, just like Notre Dame, and also don’t have a Top 25 win. The team that beat them, Ohio State, is ranked No. 12, which is *below* BYU (No. 9), the team that beat Notre Dame. And yet, Indiana is ranked fourth overall! That’s despite some super shaky recent outings and barely scraping by against unranked opponents. The “eye test” definitely isn’t being applied evenly here.
This wild inconsistency in the committee’s logic is what really has fans scratching their heads. They’re weighing things differently for practically every team, except when it comes to the SEC. For that conference, the logic is crystal clear: up, up, and away!
This is just the first set of rankings, but it’s already got us asking: what kind of crazy ride are we in for the rest of the season? We’ll be watching every Tuesday for more committee “logic” as this wild college football season keeps rolling.
This article was created with AI assistance and published under Seattle On Tap’s editorial standards. See our Editorial Policy.
Originally reported by Yahoo Sports.
Leave a Reply