
Eagles QB Joe Milton III, making only his second start for Philadelphia on Sunday in place of the benched Tanner McKee and sidelined starter Jalen Hurts, found himself in hot water immediately when a seemingly routine fumble brought back infamous memories of Cam Newton’s Super Bowl 50 no-effort play. It was a moment that could define an early career, for all the wrong reasons.
The Fumble That Had Everyone Watching (Except Milton)
It was only Philadelphia’s second play from scrimmage. Steelers pass rusher Alex Highsmith got to Milton in the backfield and stripped the ball. Fumbles happen, right? That’s football. But it wasn’t the fumble itself that drew the ire of fans and sparked immediate comparisons across the league. It was Milton’s stunning response to the loose ball. As the pigskin hit the ground near his feet, Milton wasn’t tackled. He just stood there. He watched it. No dive, no lunge, no effort to secure the ball he had a clear chance to recover. Thankfully for the Eagles, left tackle Jordan Mailata was Johnny-on-the-spot, securing the ball before Highsmith could get to it. Mailata’s hustle saved the drive and probably saved Milton from an even bigger firestorm. The Eagles even managed to convert that recovery into an early 3-0 lead.
Shades of Super Bowl 50, And That’s a Problem
That split-second lack of effort immediately sent minds rocketing back to Super Bowl 50. Remember that one? Carolina Panthers vs. Denver Broncos, fourth quarter, Panthers trailing by six points. Broncos pass rusher Von Miller stripped Cam Newton of the ball. Just like Milton on Sunday, Newton had a shot at recovering it, and just like Milton, he made no effort. The Broncos recovered Newton’s fumble deep in Carolina territory, effectively sealing a 24-10 Denver win. The stakes in that moment were, of course, monumentally higher than an early-season fumble against the Steelers. Milton’s lack of effort won’t go down in infamy like Newton’s, mainly because Mailata bailed him out. But the fact that his second career start is already drawing comparisons to one of the most infamously criticized plays in Super Bowl history? That’s not the kind of attention any quarterback wants.
Milton is trying to make his mark, trying to win over the home crowd while Jalen Hurts is sidelined and Tanner McKee has been benched. You have to wonder if this early, glaring misstep, even though it ended favorably, will stick with him. You just can’t afford moments like that when you’re fighting for a spot.
This article was created with AI assistance and published under Seattle On Tap’s editorial standards. See our Editorial Policy.
Originally reported by Yahoo Sports.
Leave a Reply