Seattle sports, on tap daily

Morgan Rogers’ Handball Penalty Was Correct, And Nobody In The Premier League Is Ready For That

Spain flag on gradient background

Written by

in

Spain flag on gradient background
Spain flag on gradient background — Created by the Sports On Tap desk | Source : Sports On Tap (team logos property of their respective owners)

Chelsea got absolutely shellacked 4-1 at home by Leeds on Saturday, and it wasn’t just the scoreline that had everyone talking. A crucial penalty against Morgan Rogers put Leeds ahead for the first time, sparking the usual outcry about officials not using “common sense.” Seriously, how many times have we heard that one? But here’s the shocker: the refs got this one right, and it might make you rethink how these calls actually work.

Handball? Not as Common as You Think, But the Rules Are Clear

Everyone always screams for a more lenient interpretation when a handball penalty is given, usually based on “perceived intent.” But here’s the wild part: despite all the chatter, handball penalties are actually way rarer in the Premier League compared to other top European leagues. Last season, the English top flight had just 22 penalties for handball across 380 games. That’s easily the lowest tally. Compare that to Spain’s La Liga with 36, or Italy’s Serie A with 38. Even this season, we’ve only seen three in 106 Premier League matches, less than what we saw in 2025-26. So, when one *is* called, there’s usually a solid reason.

Why That Rogers Call Was Spot On, Even if It Felt Harsh

So, why did referee Michael Oliver point to the spot against Morgan Rogers, and why did VAR Michael Salisbury not intervene? Because, believe it or not, the rules were crystal clear. Premier League clubs generally agree that a handball is punishable if the arm is fully extended, raised, or a deliberate act. And it’s that “deliberate act” that applied to Rogers, even if it seemed a bit harsh given the Premier League’s reputation for a more relaxed interpretation.

Here’s the breakdown: first, Jayden Bogle’s shot came from distance. That means a defender is expected to have more time to adjust and avoid a handball. But the most crucial part was Rogers’ arm movement. When Bogle shot, Rogers’ arm wasn’t raised initially, but it came up into the ball’s flight path. The key detail? If his arm had stayed in its original, lower position, there would have been no offense. But he raised it, deflecting the ball away, and that’s considered a deliberate act. This trumps all other considerations. There was a slight question about whether the ball hit too high on his arm, but it looked like it was in the “red zone,” the part of the arm where handball is punishable. That would have been the only reason for a VAR review, but it fell within the rules. We even saw a similar case last season, where the judgment of a handball offense was highlighted, coincidentally involving a penalty awarded to Leeds against Everton’s James Tarkowski, whose arm was tucked tightly to his side. It shows just how nuanced these calls can be, and how often what feels like a bad call is actually right by the book.

This article was created with AI assistance and published under Seattle On Tap’s editorial standards. See our Editorial Policy.

Originally reported by Yahoo Sports.

About the author

Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *