
The new “Madden” movie, fresh on Prime Video this week, is getting absolutely roasted like a Thanksgiving turducken, and honestly, it is an insult. This film was supposed to be a biopic honoring the Super Bowl-winning coach, incredible broadcaster, and video game visionary who captured generations with his fun spirit. Instead, it left real Madden fans like me totally pissed off. How did they do John Madden so dirty?
This Is Not the Madden We Grew Up Loving
Look, I watched this thing Wednesday night, texting back and forth with my buddy J.D., my high school QB and fellow Madden fanatic. He was just as angry. You gotta understand how much ’90s kids, guys like us, absolutely adored Madden. Our dads talked about “The Raider Way” and those 1970s Oakland teams he coached. I can still recite “The Autumn Wind” way faster than any Shakespeare sonnet from high school, for real. We loved him and Pat Summerall in the booth, that deadpan play-by-play from Summerall perfectly meshing with Madden’s totally off-the-wall commentary. He could go anywhere! The Gatorade family tree, the telestrator, the way he screamed “Brett Favre!” It was the best announcing team ever, hands down. J.D. and I even built a team in “Madden 2002” back in college, all Big Ten players with Eddie George and Mike Alstott in the backfield. We ran the ball, a lot. That video game was a guaranteed, every-year purchase. That was John Madden. He captured football fans’ imaginations like nobody before him. And in a space that feels devoid of creative thought, we got *that* movie the week before Thanksgiving NFL games? It is an insult, not just to us, but to John Madden himself.
Where the Movie Completely Fumbled the Play
Let’s be fair, Nicolas Cage had an impossible task. Love Cage, but trying to play Madden? No chance. Who could, really? The biggest issue is this movie should have been *fun*, because that was the whole Madden experience. Sporting News even ranked the top 32 football movies before this thing dropped. Madden had cameos in “Little Giants” and “The Replacements,” and those are, without question, two of the most fun football movies ever. This new film? Not a fun watch. What was the goal here? To show his relationship with Raiders owner Al Davis? Christian Bale’s performance as Davis was the highlight, which tells you everything you need to know. It blows through Madden’s three huge acts, coach, broadcaster, and video game revolutionary, at hyper-speed. There is nothing to latch onto, just a few moments showing his humanity. We needed more of that! Madden was the guy who would stay in the hospital with New England receiver Darryl Stingley. He would help his successor Tom Flores. He was the guy at the bar, Miller Lite in hand, telling you the perfect play to beat a Cover 4 defense. Madden was larger-than-life, hard-working, and that is why every ’90s kid who ever put on shoulder pads adored him.
This movie, released right before Thanksgiving football, was a huge missed opportunity to celebrate a true icon who defined football for millions. It completely failed to honor the legend.
This article was created with AI assistance and published under Seattle On Tap’s editorial standards. See our Editorial Policy.
Originally reported by The Sporting News.
Leave a Reply