PFF just dropped their latest NFL secondary rankings for 2026, and the Indianapolis Colts are stuck right in the middle, snagging the No. 16 spot among all 32 teams. For a squad that’s supposed to be bringing some serious talent to the field, that’s gotta sting a bit. You look at that roster and think, “No. 16? Seriously?”
Why Is This Group Not Cracking the Top Tier?
The hesitation from PFF is pretty clear, and it makes you wonder what’s really going on behind the scenes. Last season, in 2025, the Colts’ defense was giving up more explosive pass plays of 15-plus yards than any other team in the entire NFL. That’s a huge red flag, no matter how much talent you stack up. PFF’s Daire Carragher didn’t pull any punches, noting just how tough this secondary is to evaluate precisely because they’ve barely played together as a unit. Carragher himself admitted, “This is a difficult secondary to place, so I’ve dropped them right into the middle of the pack.” That kind of uncertainty is exactly what keeps a group from climbing higher, even with big names on the depth chart. It’s all about proving it on the field, not just on paper.
The Talent Is There, But the Chemistry Is a Question Mark
Here’s the thing, the Colts aren’t “starved of talent” in the secondary. They acquired All-Pro Sauce Gardner during the 2025 season, pairing him up with Charvarius Ward. That’s a duo that *should* be making waves, right? But the catch is, injuries held them back big time, limiting those two to just one full game playing together. One game! How can you build any kind of rhythm or understanding with that kind of disruption? Then you’ve got Justin Walley back in the mix after missing his entire rookie season with a torn ACL. And rookie A.J. Haulcy is already sitting atop the depth chart at strong safety, while veteran Cam Bynum holds down free safety. On paper, that’s a mix of proven stars, returning potential, and fresh blood. It’s a lot of moving pieces, and if they can’t stay healthy and play together, that talent becomes just potential.
With a lineup featuring Gardner, Ward, Walley, Haulcy, and Bynum, that No. 16 ranking really does feel more like a “cautious projection” than any kind of final verdict on what this secondary can truly achieve. The potential is absolutely there for them to outperform that PFF slot, but they have to actually go out and do it. For the Colts, the early season isn’t just about winning games, it’s about seeing if this group can finally gel, cut down on those explosive plays, and show the league that their true potential is way higher than “middle of the pack.” Keep an eye on them, because if these guys click, that ranking will look like a joke by season’s end.
This article was created with AI assistance and published under Seattle On Tap’s editorial standards. See our Editorial Policy.
Originally reported by Yahoo Sports.
Leave a Reply