Seattle sports, on tap daily

Shane Steichen Is Benching Anthony Richardson Sr., And Indianapolis Fans Should Be Furious

Indianapolis Colts logo on gradient background

Written by

in

Indianapolis Colts logo on gradient background
Indianapolis Colts logo on gradient background — Created by the Sports On Tap desk | Source : Sports On Tap (team logos property of their respective owners)

The Indianapolis Colts’ 2026 NFL season is a complete disaster, no sugarcoating it. They are absolutely headed for one of the top picks in the upcoming NFL draft, but here is the kicker: they already sent their 2027 first-rounder to the New York Jets for Sauce Gardner. With the Colts struggling hard, even against teams like the Miami Dolphins, you’d think changes would be coming, right? Especially at quarterback where Daniel Jones has been, well, rough. But according to ESPN’s Jeremy Fowler, the Colts are *not* turning to Anthony Richardson Sr. this season, and for Colts fans, that has to be a soul-crushing update.

Steichen’s Stance on the Future QB

So, why the cold shoulder for Richardson? Fowler reported it straight: head coach Shane Steichen “simply is not motivated to play Anthony Richardson Sr.” Let that sink in. This is the 2023 fourth overall pick, a guy who actually had a strong start to his rookie year before he fell out of favor. Meanwhile, Jones is out there playing like one of the worst quarterbacks in the entire NFL. He’s led the team to a dismal 3-7 record and just isn’t giving them a real shot to win games. You’d think that would be all the reason in the world to make a change, right? But even with all these glaring offensive issues, the Colts are dug in. There won’t be a QB change this season, at least not to Richardson. And get this: if they *do* bench Jones, the next guy up might not even be Richardson. Riley Leonard is apparently the one who “might be the QB1 in Indianapolis” if Jones gets benched. Steichen, it seems, has zero plans for Richardson this year.

Why Winning Now Is A Trap

Fowler put it plain: “I just don’t see Steichen benching Jones right now unless absolutely necessary.” The Colts aren’t contending for a playoff spot this year, especially not after they were sellers at the trade deadline. But without their own first-round pick next year, Steichen and the front office are still trying to win every single week. That means the best quarterback for the job, in Steichen’s eyes, is Jones. It’s a brutal Catch-22 for Indianapolis: they are not good, they gave away their future draft capital, and they’re still not willing to give their potential future star quarterback a real look. Richardson might be a higher-upside option, and a much more exciting starter than Jones, but Colts fans are probably not going to see the former No. 3 overall pick take the field this season. This was the perfect time to get a real look at him, too. What a mess.

It feels like a head-scratcher for a team in such a bind. While the Colts are navigating this quarterback conundrum, at least we in Seattle are seeing some absolute fireworks! Speaking of exciting performances, our very own Jaxon Smith-Njigba just keeps balling out, joining Tyreek Hill in an exclusive club with another explosive performance. Yeah, some teams are actually building for the future while winning now. You just hate to see it happen to a team when they refuse to play a player like Richardson.

This article was created with AI assistance and published under Seattle On Tap’s editorial standards. See our Editorial Policy.

Originally reported by The Sporting News.

About the author

Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *