Seattle sports, on tap daily

Trev Alberts Said ‘It Depends’ on Coach-Athlete Sex, and Michigan’s AD Hire Is Already a Mess

Ncaab on gradient background

Written by

in

Ncaab on gradient background
Ncaab on gradient background — Created by the Sports On Tap desk | Source : Sports On Tap (team logos property of their respective owners)

Trev Alberts, set to become Michigan’s next athletic director, dropped a bombshell in a December 2025 deposition, stating “it depends” when asked if college coaches should ever have sexual relationships with athletes. This isn’t just a slip of the tongue, folks. This is a massive statement that is already shaking things up before he even officially steps into the role.

The Nebraska Lawsuit and Scoggin’s Allegations

This eyebrow-raising comment came out during a federal lawsuit where Alberts was a defendant. The suit alleges he and other officials at Nebraska, where he was AD from 2021-24, completely bungled a sexual relationship situation. We’re talking about an associate women’s basketball coach, Chuck Love, and a player, Ashley Scoggin, who played for the school from 2020-22 before heading to UNLV. Scoggin’s lawsuit claims the university left her hanging, failing to protect her or properly investigate how Love allegedly “groomed” her into a secret relationship. Think about that: a player feeling unprotected. The lawsuit didn’t stop there, either. It alleges Alberts didn’t even question head coach Amy Williams’ decision to kick Scoggin off the team. Plus, he supposedly didn’t investigate if Love had other relationships with students, failed to demand employee training, and didn’t clarify policies banning these kinds of relationships. To top it off, the lawsuit claims Alberts pushed Scoggin to leave Nebraska and let Love just resign voluntarily in 2022. Alberts’ and Williams’ attorneys, for their part, denied Scoggin’s claims, saying they were completely in the dark until a Title IX complaint landed in March 2022.

“It Depends” and the Fallout

During about seven hours of depositions, Scoggin’s attorney, Maren Chaloupka, grilled Alberts on whether he believed college coaches should *never* have sex with athletes, especially given the university’s own policy forbidding faculty-student relationships. Alberts’ response? He “didn’t know the answer to that” and then went with “it depends,” adding there was “nuance.” He even brought up post-COVID eligibility rules, saying some students are “25, 26 years old” and some coaches might be “27, 28.” Seriously, nuance? He then added that if they “think that’s happening, that’s when we are not encouraged, but trained to report it to the experts.” He stressed, “We are not experts in this. I’m not an expert in that area. And I don’t make that judgment.” Well, Aaron Hernandez, the director of the National Sports Law Institute at Marquette, told the Detroit News that Alberts’ answer was “problematic.” Hernandez put it bluntly: “The way to answer a question like that is ‘We don’t want our coaches doing that.’” He nailed it when he said, “The fact that he danced around it is probably not the route Michigan wants to go with given their own situation.” These comments, first reported by David Covucci of FOIAball, aren’t just a misstep, they are a massive problem.

This whole “it depends” answer from Alberts becomes incredibly relevant, doesn’t it? He’s expected to take over the athletic department at Michigan, succeeding Warde Manuel. This isn’t just about a past incident; it’s about the leadership and judgment he’s bringing to a massive program. How is Michigan going to navigate this as he steps into the AD role? This isn’t just some run-of-the-mill hire, it’s a statement on the values of the entire university.

This article was created with AI assistance and published under Seattle On Tap’s editorial standards. See our Editorial Policy.

Originally reported by Yahoo Sports.

About the author

Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *