
The 2026 Yankees’ ALDS loss to the Rays was a tough pill to swallow, but now the Pinstripe Alley staff just dropped their full Roster Report Card series, and some of these grades? Man, they’re straight-up brutal as we head into the offseason. This whole series started back in mid-October and it’s gonna run right through early December, breaking down who really delivered and who… well, who didn’t.
Too Much Red Ink After a Disappointing Season
You gotta be kidding me with some of these. After a season that ended short of expectations, multiple guys got hit with F grades. We’re talking about **Amed Rosario**, **Jasson Domínguez**, **Jake Bird**, **Luis Gil**, and **Camilo Doval** all getting straight-up Fs. That’s a lot of talent, or at least potential, not living up to it. Then you’ve got **J.C. Escarra** pulling a D-, **Trent Grisham** with a D, and **Jazz Chisholm Jr.** and **Tim Hill** just barely doing better with D+ marks. That’s a serious chunk of the roster that just didn’t cut it. It really makes you wonder what was going on out there, especially after such a disappointing end to the year.
Not All Bad, But the Bar Was Low
It wasn’t all doom and gloom, thankfully. Some guys really showed up. **David Bednar**, **Paul Blackburn**, and **Brent Headrick** all earned A grades, which is awesome, right? **Max Fried** wasn’t far behind with an A-. And then we’ve got solid B+ performances from **Cody Bellinger** and **Gerrit Cole**, which you’d expect from those guys. **Paul Goldschmidt** and **Ryan Yarbrough** got Bs, while **Fernando Cruz** and **Luis García Jr.** pulled B- grades. **José Caballero** got a C+, which is okay, I guess. We also saw John Schreiber and Angel Chivilli get ‘Incompletes,’ so the jury’s still out on their full picture.
The Offseason Just Got More Interesting
This is just the start, folks. The Pinstripe Alley crew is gonna keep dropping these report cards throughout the offseason, all the way until early December. We’ve still got huge names like **Spencer Jones** coming up tomorrow, **Aaron Judge** on November 19, and even **Giancarlo Stanton** set for December 3. Plus, they mentioned that manager Aaron Boone and general manager Brian Cashman have their own separate evaluations, so you know those are going to be hot takes. What do these grades mean for the team’s future? Which players are on the hot seat? It’s going to be a fascinating few weeks as these final evaluations come out and the front office starts making moves.
This article was created with AI assistance and published under Seattle On Tap’s editorial standards. See our Editorial Policy.
Originally reported by Yahoo Sports.
Leave a Reply