Yankees Have ‘No Idea’ if Aaron Judge Will Play Again: What That Means for Their Playoff Run

MLB insider Bob Nightengale just dropped a bombshell: the New York Yankees have “no idea” if three-time MVP Aaron Judge will play again this season. That’s a gut punch for a team already locked into the postseason, especially with the playoffs just weeks away and them still fighting to make up ground in the AL East race.

Judge’s Rollercoaster Year Takes Another Turn

This whole season has been a wild ride for Judge, who’s been out for most of it. He first hit the injured list right after May ended. He did make it back for a bit in August, which was a huge relief for Yankees fans, especially since he’d been sidelined for a long time before that due to a rib issue. But here’s the kicker: he came back without a rehab assignment, jumping straight into big-league action. Turns out, that might’ve been too soon. Judge tweaked his calf, and boom, back on the injured list for a second time. This time, it’s a right calf strain, which means he’ll miss at least 10 days, effectively bringing him to the end of the regular season.

Playoff Hopes on Shaky Ground Without Their MVP

Nightengale wasn’t subtle about it, writing that the Yankees are “bracing themselves now for the possibility that their three-time MVP may not play again the rest of the season.” Think about that for a second. Even if he *does* somehow make it back for the playoffs, there’s going to be massive concern about his production. His health questions would be super real, and manager Aaron Boone basically confirmed the uncertainty, telling reporters, “I don’t know,” when asked about Judge’s potential return.

You gotta feel for Yankees fans here. Expecting to go into the playoffs, or even finish out the AL East race, without their main man is rough. They’re sitting at 89-64, they’ve clinched a postseason spot, but every game counts when you’re trying to gain ground. Judge is a key to their success in the postseason, and his return is completely unknown as they get ready for October. The rest of the 2026 season, including the playoffs, might just be a Judge-less affair.

This article was created with AI assistance and published under Seattle On Tap’s editorial standards. See our Editorial Policy.

Originally reported by The Sporting News.